In January, I walked up the entrance steps of a single-storey, grey-shingled home in a neighbourhood on the perimeter of Stanford College. The second I pressed the video doorbell, I heard Sam Bankman-Fried’s voice calling from inside. “I’ll get it!” His father acquired to the door first. Joe Bankman and Barbara Fried, each professors, welcomed me with the courtesy and gentle indifference of fogeys greeting a teen coming over to hang around with their son after college.
The household’s placid suburban home and backyard, the place hummingbirds buzzed over a small fountain, had been overshadowed by the authorized disaster bearing down on the 30-year-old who resides within the sitting room. Sam Bankman-Fried, broadly often called SBF, faces US legal and civil fees, together with cash laundering, marketing campaign finance violations and conspiracy to commit wire fraud. He’s accused of absconding with billions of {dollars} of purchasers’ cash. Two of his lieutenants at his firms Alameda Analysis and FTX have pleaded responsible to fraud and are anticipated to testify in opposition to him. Bankman-Fried maintains his innocence.
The explanations for SBF’s notoriety are plentiful. Since 2019, when he based FTX, an alternate enabling clients to commerce digital and bodily currencies, the younger man with the hobbit-like look has reduce an uncommon determine among the many world monetary and political elite. Bankman-Fried was wincingly earnest when he spoke in public about efficient altruism, Silicon Valley’s faddish philosophy of philanthropy, or about FTX’s plans to legitimise the world of crypto, or, as his firm grew, buying Goldman Sachs. He wholeheartedly embraced his picture as a shambolic boy genius and, price greater than $20bn at his peak, he cheerily vowed to present all of it away.
As a substitute, he watched his firms disintegrate right into a steaming pile of economic poisonous waste. It took rather less than per week. What follows is probably the most detailed account but of FTX’s closing days. It’s primarily based on interviews with folks with first-hand data of occasions, in addition to court docket paperwork and in depth inside messages and emails, which have been minimally edited for size and readability. They present how a tiny group of millennial millionaires and life-long pals panicked and despaired as they ran a $40bn firm into the bottom.
Quite a few FTX staff spoke to me on situation of anonymity, for worry of authorized repercussions — apart from Bankman-Fried. “Simply, everybody left,” he advised me. “I couldn’t do it alone. And, if I’m alone, then possibly I’m improper. I’m fairly impervious to stress, however in some unspecified time in the future I began to really feel like possibly I’m the one who’s improper right here.”
On Monday, Bankman-Fried issued new orders to merchants at Alameda, his crypto buying and selling agency. A small group of savants, hunched behind nine-screen workstations, had been advised to begin promoting off as a lot of the corporate’s eclectic funding portfolio as they might, as quick as doable.
SIGNAL – Nov 7
Dealer: Shut all the pieces all the way down to generate capital, maximally aggressive… liquidate all positions?
SBF: There may be undoubtedly a good bit of urgency
SBF: ETA on getting no less than $2b of USD?
Bankman-Fried wanted money as a result of purchasers of his different firm, FTX, had been in a panic. Information of leaked paperwork displaying a harmful dependence on its digital forex often called FTT had been dangerous sufficient. However then, considered one of Bankman-Fried’s rivals threatened to dump some $500mn of FTT on to the market and tank its worth. Now, FTX was being overrun by withdrawals, with billions flowing out the door by the hour.
Bankman-Fried’s inside circle was principally gathered on the Albany, a 600-acre luxurious compound in Nassau, the capital of the Bahamas. The CEO lived with a rotating solid of colleagues in a five-bedroom penthouse with views of the yachts within the marina. It was considered one of a number of Albany properties the corporate purchased when it moved to the island the earlier yr. Most FTX workers had accomplished little to settle into their new properties, making a weird distinction between the glitzy actual property and the barren residences. “It was much more of a ‘very good dorm-room’ fashion than you’d anticipate,” mentioned somebody who hung out there.
Bankman-Fried was one of many elders. Gary Wang, FTX’s taciturn and solitary expertise chief, was a buddy from high-school maths camp and MIT. Nishad Singh, the quantity two coder, was a buddy of Bankman-Fried’s youthful brother and had been recruited from Fb. Singh was pleasant and outgoing, well-liked with workers. Each Wang and Singh had been courting fellow staff.
Caroline Ellison was Alameda’s 28-year-old chief govt. A Harry Potter superfan, she wrote a weblog with voluminous entries about all the pieces from her favorite books to the deserves of kayaks (“clearly among the finest methods for people to get round water”). She’d met Bankman-Fried throughout his transient stint on the Wall Road buying and selling agency Jane Road a decade in the past.
At Alameda, she was a low-key boss. “Caroline didn’t have plenty of gravitas,” mentioned one staffer. “The primary time I met her I believed she was an intern.” Ellison, who was in Hong Kong on a long-planned journey when the disaster hit, had been romantically concerned with Bankman-Fried the yr earlier than. Since their relationship ended, communication between the 2 had been inconsistent and, at instances, awkward.
Attorneys for Wang and Singh declined to remark. Ellison’s lawyer didn’t reply to requests for remark.
Bankman-Fried minimised the disaster FTX was dealing with as a “liquidity” subject, which means the corporate didn’t have sufficient money available to satisfy withdrawals. It was an enormous drawback, however a fixable one. He disregarded the thought of submitting for chapter safety, which might, in impact, be conceding there have been profound points on the core of the enterprise. Satisfied he may fundraise his method out of hassle, Bankman-Fried ignored issues that bringing in extra money from buyers could be perpetuating an alleged fraud to cowl losses.
When senior executives exterior Bankman-Fried’s circle pored over spreadsheets, they reached a special conclusion. “It’s not liquidity. It’s fucking solvency. It’s an enormous, gaping gap in buyer property,” mentioned one high govt, describing the realisation that cash FTX promised to safeguard was lacking. “It was such an unbelievable shock to the system,” mentioned one other former senior govt. As phrase unfold, the management fractured into two opposing camps. The “Bahamas staff” gathered round Bankman-Fried on the Caribbean island, as he frantically hit the telephones, in search of buyers. In New York, an opposing group started planning for the worst. Former staff referred to as them “the adults.”
A hurricane was barrelling in direction of headquarters, however FTX staff in Nassau awoke on Tuesday to sunny skies. Many headed into the workplace, a crowded string of low terracotta-coloured buildings in a waterfront workplace park, regardless of the storm warning. After they learnt withdrawals from the alternate had been halted, many staff realised their private financial savings had been trapped too. “Nobody had rushed to take out their very own cash,” mentioned one. “We had excessive religion within the firm and Sam himself.”
As rank-and-file workers waited for an replace, FTX’s management tried to get a deal with on the disaster. A “struggle room” had been arrange in Bankman-Fried’s penthouse and far of the tech staff, afraid to speak brazenly concerning the firm’s misery, moved there. Bankman-Fried’s right-hand in his fundraising drive was Constance Wang, FTX’s chief working officer. In her late-twenties, she had spent two years as a Credit score Suisse analyst and had two quick stints at different crypto companies earlier than touchdown the high-profile position at FTX. She’d overseen a lot of the corporate’s star-studded advertising and hosted almost-weekly events at her Nassau villa.
It was 2am in Hong Kong when Lennix Lai’s cellphone buzzed. A high govt at rival crypto alternate OKX, Lai picked as much as discover Bankman-Fried on the opposite finish of the road. Market panic had created a money crunch, and FTX would possibly want “a bit little bit of assist,” he advised Lai calmly. Clients had been withdrawing cash at an unsustainable charge. Lai ended the decision open to lending a hand.
Round 7am, he woke as much as one other name from Nassau. The numbers Bankman-Fried threw out had been gorgeous: FTX wanted “a pair billion” {dollars} instantly to keep away from “very critical penalties”. Delay would trigger the opening to develop to between $4bn and $8bn.
Bankman-Fried as soon as boasted to a reporter that he was “one of many world’s biggest fundraisers.” He had raised $1.8bn since 2019, regardless of typically showing to not strive very laborious. In a single profitable pitch assembly with high enterprise capitalists that grew to become a part of his legend, he’d performed video video games all through. Now, his sizzling streak ended. He was turned down first by a handful of personal fairness corporations, then by his largest rivals, together with Coinbase, Huobi and OKX. VCs wouldn’t chew both. Lai was simply considered one of many who was not ready to write down a cheque. However earlier than he hung up, he gave Bankman-Fried some recommendation: “Why not converse to CZ?”
“CZ” is Changpeng Zhao, crypto’s biggest tycoon. The 45-year-old Canadian-Chinese language CEO of Binance, the world’s largest crypto alternate, is in some ways Bankman-Fried’s reverse. CZ’s massive, spherical head of buzzed hair and bespectacled eyes give him an air of intense focus. On the peak of the crypto market in 2021, he was mentioned to be the richest man on the earth. However these estimates are hazy as a result of CZ’s wealth, and Binance’s possession construction, are obscured by a jumble of offshore firms. CZ was an early investor in FTX, however he and Bankman-Fried fell out over their totally different approaches to regulation. The 2 firms’ workers had come to view one another with enmity.
Finally, Bankman-Fried had no selection however to heed Lai’s recommendation. He despatched a string of “more and more determined” messages to his arch-rival. “When he reached out to me, I believed he was going to ask for a [private] deal to purchase the FTT tokens… However when he referred to as me, he in a short time alluded that they’re in massive hassle, they usually’re in search of a buyout,” CZ later mentioned, at a convention. “I knew he was determined.”
The push to boost cash appeared outrageous to some executives. Dan Friedberg, FTX’s high lawyer since 2020, thought making an attempt to fundraise seemed like an extension of a probable fraud, he later claimed, in accordance with court docket paperwork. Different executives felt the identical. “I had the priority that… elevating cash was fraudulent if we didn’t inform folks what was actually occurring,” mentioned one.
The flurry of exercise was unknown to most of FTX’s workers. “The fact is that on the time there was no communication from the chief staff to the workers, and I actually didn’t perceive it,” mentioned an worker. “Folks had been getting panicked internally,” mentioned one other. “I saved sending Sam messages on Sign. He was not even studying my messages.”
When Bankman-Fried lastly broke his silence, it was to announce that Binance had agreed to purchase FTX. But it surely was little greater than a handshake. There had been no time to hammer out phrases, and CZ reserved the fitting to stroll away after wanting over his competitor’s books. There wasn’t even a price for the transaction. Nonetheless, it appeared to validate Bankman-Fried and the Bahamas staff’s perception that the corporate may survive.
Bankman-Fried shared the information on Twitter an hour earlier than FTX’s weekly all-hands assembly. He additionally posted a Slack message to his few hundred staff.
SLACK – nov 8
SBF: I’m sorry that I haven’t been very communicative in the previous couple of days — we’ve been determining what to do in actual time… You may need utterly affordable questions for me, like “what precisely is the transaction”, and “what entities wouldn’t it embrace”. Sadly I don’t but have a definitive reply for you.
Employees clustered across the massive display screen within the nook of the Nassau workplace to look at. Staff had been used to listening to concerning the firm’s newest progress and quizzing their usually loquacious boss. “[But] that was the primary time that Sam refused to take questions,” mentioned one worker. Many interpreted this as a foul signal. “The message was: ‘We’re fucked. I fucked up,’” one other mentioned.
The announcement of the sale to Binance broke many staffers’ spirits. FTX billed itself as pro-regulation, a righteous pressure within the typically shady crypto world. Binance was seen as the alternative, having refused to even identify a location for its headquarters to keep away from oversight. To FTX workers, it was like Luke Skywalker becoming a member of Darth Vader. “That second created panic,” mentioned an worker. “Nobody anticipated it.”
A lot of them began quitting. Quickly, information of FTX’s troubles was spreading past headquarters. Rental automotive businesses in Nassau demanded their automobiles again. Motels and landlords turned out FTX staff, a few of whom moved into properties owned by the corporate. Many employees rushed to e-book tickets off the island. “If you happen to may get a flight out tomorrow, you’d go,” one recalled.
When rumours unfold that FTX workers had been being searched on the airport, colleagues began throwing out any article of clothes imprinted with the corporate’s brand. “It was this mixture of an actual, bodily hurricane and a psychological hurricane,” mentioned one worker. “It was probably the most loopy, hectic 24 hours of my life. I felt like my worldview was falling aside. FTX was not only a job for me and for different folks. FTX was my life.”
The considered authorized threat weighed closely on Ryne Miller, FTX US’s 40-year-old common counsel in New York. An enormous bear of a person with a grizzled beard, Miller had not adopted the standard gold-plated street from Ivy League legislation college to Wall Road. Miller, who corrected colleagues who pronounced his identify “Ryan” (it’s extra like “Rhine”), studied legislation in Oklahoma and labored at a regional agency earlier than working his method as much as a job on the Commodity Futures Buying and selling Fee (CFTC), the US regulator. In mid-2021, Miller left a partnership at Sullivan & Cromwell, a high Wall Road agency often called S&C, to affix FTX.
Some within the Bahamas had been suspicious of Miller, seeing him extra as a creature of the US authorized world than a crypto diehard. However even staff who disliked him revered his abilities. “Ryne is a pointy fucking lawyer,” mentioned one. Now, Miller rapidly grew to become the Bahamas staff’s major antagonist. “I believe Ryne, as a lawyer, was like ‘holy shit,’” mentioned a former colleague. “If you happen to realise that some horrible crime simply came about, you don’t hold some a part of the enterprise operating.” Miller declined to remark.
On Tuesday morning, Miller and Can Solar, FTX Worldwide’s common counsel, referred to as an pressing video assembly with Andy Dietderich, a associate at S&C. Dietderich’s soft-spoken method belied his repute as an aggressive lawyer. As quickly as he clicked the Zoom hyperlink, he may inform one thing was improper, in accordance with an account he gave a court docket. Solar and Miller had been visibly upset. They advised him FTX didn’t have the cash to pay again clients. Dietderich was surprised to study his consumer wanted to consider chapter.
Dietderich, 53, is a veteran of what restructuring professionals name “free-fall” bankruptcies, wherein firms plunge into chapter 11 with out a restructuring plan in place. Nonetheless, he was staggered by the job in entrance of him. Bankman-Fried’s empire was hyper-complex, and it was unravelling at horrifying pace. Inside hours, Dietderich had marshalled dozens of S&C legal professionals in London, New York and Hong Kong to arrange choices for unwind greater than 100 world company entities that comprised FTX and Alameda. Additionally they drew up a listing of 4 restructuring specialists who may take management.
Miller needed to know if the issues at FTX Worldwide prolonged to its US arm, which was presupposed to function individually underneath American regulation. He started demanding solutions from Bankman-Fried’s confidantes: was FTX US really separate?
SIGNAL – NOV 8
Ryne Miller: I must know the fucking reality about FTX US proper now.
Nishad Singh: sure FTXUS needs to be completely separate
Miller was more and more pissed off by the dearth of communication from the Bahamas, as he demanded proof the US division was solvent.
SIGNAL – NOV 8
Ryne Miller: I must wire SullCrom $4m to verify we’re all represented via this. And we protect any worth that’s left. Tomorrow… Who can do it? I’m in cost now.
The opposing camps grew to become extra entrenched: the New York group struggled to arrange for what it got here to see as an inevitable chapter, whereas the one within the Bahamas tried to come back to grips with the situation wherein FTX would, ultimately, be swallowed by Binance.
The final time FTX workers gathered in any energy of numbers was Tuesday evening at Bankman-Fried’s penthouse, the place a number of dozen staff sat in small teams, some in tears. Rain was beginning to sweep in off the ocean, splashing on to the broad balcony bathed in blue spotlights. Singh’s two labradoodles wandered via the residence, nuzzling as much as the downcast 20-somethings. “We had been in complete shock,” one worker mentioned. “It lastly hit me that we misplaced tremendously. I cried my eyes out.”
A lot of them wore FTX-branded garments and joked about needing to embroider “powered by Binance” underneath the outdated brand. The catering workers, extra accustomed to seeing the gang of crypto nerds both working or celebrating, had been stunned. “It felt like being on the collapse of Rome,” one attendee mentioned. Somebody quietly requested a server to take an uneaten dessert away. The chocolate pudding topped with gold flakes appeared like one thing from a earlier period.
Rumours of the Binance deal rapidly drew inquiries from Bahamian officers frightened concerning the destiny of one of many nation’s most well-known employers. The Caribbean nation had developed bespoke regulation for crypto and welcomed Bankman-Fried with open arms. His firm had good relations with Ryan Pinder, the attorney-general, in addition to Christina Rolle, the highest monetary regulator. Now, each wanted solutions.
EMAIL – NOV 8, 11:37
FROM: CHRISTINA ROLLE
TO: SAM BANKMAN-FRIED
Good morning… Please advise your availability to satisfy with the Securities Fee of The Bahamas to debate current press relating to liquidity points in addition to the potential acquisition of FTX by Binance…
EMAIL – NOV 8, 14:48
FROM: SAM BANKMAN-FRIED
TO: CHRISTINA ROLLE
Hey! I’m fairly pressed for time however will make it possible for we speak to you ASAP; I’ll briefly say that, as of now, no sale has occurred or been finalized though there are energetic talks. We’ll hold you up to date about these
EMAIL – NOV 8, 11:29
FROM: RYAN PINDER
TO: SAM BANKMAN-FRIED
Good morning, I do know it have to be a busy time. Is there extra data you may share with us relating to the purported [agreement] between FTX and Binance? Ryan
EMAIL – NOV 8, 16:58
FROM: DANIEL FRIEDBERG
TO: RYAN PINDER
Hello Ryan — sorry for the delay. Can Solar [FTX International’s general counsel] is on island and can coordinate.
Dan Friedberg opposed a US chapter. The corporate had already turned off the faucet for consumer withdrawals; different crypto exchanges had frozen funds for weeks and survived. If it got here to it, FTX ought to file for insolvency abroad. Chapter within the US introduced the dangers of regulatory scrutiny and the interference of legal professionals inexperienced in crypto. “You might have a bunch of individuals coming in who don’t know the enterprise in any respect,” mentioned one govt of that situation. “It’s simply going to be a shitshow.”
However by late Tuesday, each Friedberg and Solar had resigned. Solar emailed colleagues to say he stop. Friedberg appeared to “disappear,” in accordance with colleagues. Solar declined to remark. Friedberg didn’t reply to requests for remark.
The resignations left Miller because the senior lawyer for FTX US and Tim Wilson, who had additionally labored at S&C earlier in his profession, because the remaining lawyer for FTX Worldwide. “Ryne noticed the FTX scenario as much like the Merrill Lynch scenario or Lehman in 2009,” mentioned a former colleague. Miller’s former agency had dealt with Lehman, the biggest chapter in US historical past. Wilson didn’t reply to requests for remark.
SIGNAL – NOV 9 10:38
Ryne Miller: We have to herald an expert supervisor who will start making actual choices (supported by enter from this group) in direction of wind down (SullCrom will determine and produce on this particular person). Binance understands that course of wants to begin, and actually it would give them a correct level of contact as wind down proceeds and the “deal” between them and FTX begins to take form…
Zach Dexter, one of many firm’s high US executives, pasted a hyperlink to a information story many had already learn. It claimed that Binance was going to stroll away from the deal as a result of its first take a look at FTX’s books allegedly confirmed misappropriation of buyer funds. The following message and e mail exchanges, elements of which had been beforehand reported by the New York Occasions, present the divisions about proceed. Dexter didn’t reply to requests for remark.
Ryne Miller: Spoke to Binance authorized this morning as a diligence kick-off. Was very high-level they usually mentioned they might follow-up. I should not have a direct contact there past that decision.
SBF (reply to Dexter): They hadn’t reached out to us about that, haven’t heard something from them straight, reaching out
SBF (reply to Miller): On a name, sec
Caroline Ellison: Proper now I’m pondering of [communicating to employees] a vibe of ‘Alameda might be going to wind down, in the event you don’t wish to keep or wish to take a while off no stress, in the event you do wish to assist with stuff like ensuring our lenders get repaid it’s tremendous appreciated’
Caroline Ellison: Did this… although now I’m kinda frightened that everybody is gonna stop/take day without work and I’m going to finish up making an attempt to unwind all our positions myself
Any person within the group chat chimed in to ask, “Can we provide some bonus… for folks to work via this? I do know there’s not a ton of $ however possibly one thing?” Miller replied:
Ryne Miller: No. We must always proceed to make payroll as quick as that’s doable. Different expenditures sharply curtailed.
In the meantime, Bankman-Fried tried to get solutions out of CZ. An individual who noticed the messages learn them to me over the cellphone:
TEXT – NOV 9
SBF: Hey, we’re nonetheless extraordinarily excited to work on this with you guys. We’re clearly seeing plenty of public items popping out claiming leaks, however we clearly don’t know if that’s actual. We might like to get readability from you guys on this, and we’re prepared to do something to make this work
CZ: Sam, we received’t be capable of proceed this deal. Manner too many points. CZ
The collapse of the Binance deal strengthened the case for chapter. Determined for a authorized second opinion to counter Miller and Wilson’s appeals, Bankman-Fried turned to his father, Stanford professor Joe Bankman, a specialist in tax legislation who had served as an adviser to his son earlier than and had flown from California to affix him within the Bahamas. Because the disaster deepened on Wednesday, some FTX executives had been blowing the whistle to regulators.
Ryne Miller: Primarily based on what we’re studying… and primarily based on recommendation of Sullivan & Cromwell, our suggestion and instruction (I’m GC of FTX US so saying what I can) is to show off buying and selling and halt exercise on each FTX US and FTX.com. After which determine a management/choice particular person to work with exterior counsel on subsequent steps. For US functions, we can be informing the CFTC, SEC, and Division of Justice that this suggestion has been made.
Bankman-Fried acknowledged the message and relayed a company-wide notice he’d simply shared.
SBF: Despatched this simply now, ack on the above: — Hey all, We clearly simply noticed Binance’s assertion; they relayed that first to the media, to not us, and had not beforehand knowledgeable us or expressed these reservations. I’m working, as rapidly as I can, on subsequent steps right here. I want I may offer you all extra readability than I can. I utterly perceive if you wish to step away, and don’t blame you in any respect for it. My targets listed here are: defending clients, doing what I can for workers and buyers. I’ll hold preventing for these, as finest I can, so long as it’s right for me to. I’m exploring all of the choices. I’m deeply sorry that we acquired into this place, and for my position in it. That’s on me, and me alone, and it sucks, and I’m sorry, not that that makes it any higher. @Zach Dexter and @Ryne Miller are good folks to contact about FTX US
Ryne Miller: Thanks @SBF @Nishad Singh @Gary Wang. Who can flip off the web sites? And who can determine, on chain, what precise property we have now for US?
Constance Wang: Hello Ryne, I really like you however I don’t wish to cease making an attempt but. I admire you letting me strive all the pieces I can and handle the scenario to offer clarities and assurance to our customers too. If nothing works I’d be comfortable to work with you on a correct wind down
Ryne Miller: I perceive your perspective, thanks. I’m not making public statements. I’ll report back to our US regulators in step with our obligations.
That afternoon, Miller joined Ryan Salame, chair of the FTX’s Bahamas company entity, on a video assembly with the top of the island’s securities regulator, Christina Rolle. Based on Rolle’s sworn account, Salame advised the authorities that FTX consumer property had been transferred to Alameda with out their data or consent. This seemed to Rolle like a doable crime. She ended the decision and phoned the police.
EMAIL – NOV 9, 08:03
FROM: RYAN PINDER
TO: SAM BANKMAN-FRIED
The Authorities of The Bahamas want to ask some questions, and get an replace on the present scenario. I can be briefing the Prime Minister later in the present day. Are you able to please help with a briefing replace in addition to addressing the next questions…What’s the ongoing dedication to The Bahamas? Thanks, Ryan
EMAIL – NOV 9, 16:16
FROM: SAM BANKMAN-FRIED
TO: RYAN PINDER
Sorry giving updates as I can. Issues transferring rapidly. I can’t give as assured solutions as I’d wish to all of these [questions]. My present solely precedence is doing proper by clients, and doing no matter I can for that; proper now meaning prioritising, above all the pieces else, getting funding to fill the liquidity hole so that every one clients might be made liquid. cc’ing Joe/Constance/Ryan who may give extra particulars. Sam Bankman-Fried
EMAIL – NOV 9, 18:00
FROM: RYAN PINDER
TO: SAM BANKMAN-FRIED
Thanks Sam. Joe, Constance, Ryan – please present me with a quick and solutions to the questions beneath so I can present the Prime Minister an replace. Ryan
EMAIL – NOV 9, 21:27
FROM: SAM BANKMAN-FRIED
TO: RYAN PINDER
Hello all, I’m actually sorry concerning the delayed responses right here — it’s been a busy week however that’s on me. Myself, and Joe (cc’ed), can be responsive going ahead. And I’m additionally deeply sorry for ending up on this place within the first place… Proper now we’re centered on one factor: making clients entire. We’re focusing completely on doing that this week… As you noticed, Binance didn’t find yourself following via on their transaction. Nonetheless, we’re in the course of a separate course of to make customers entire; we’ll know inside per week if that comes via… We’re deeply grateful for what The Bahamas has accomplished for us, and deeply dedicated to it…”
Then, Bankman-Fried made the federal government an astonishing provide. He urged FTX could be “more than pleased” to open withdrawals for Bahamas clients. “If we don’t hear again from you,” he wrote, “we’re going to go forward and do it tomorrow.” It was an act of desperation by Bankman-Fried’s camp, in accordance with one ally. They had been panicked by rumours they had been about to be arrested and making an attempt to guess which strikes would possibly placate authorities.
Shortly after sending his late-night enchantment to the attorney-general, one other e mail dropped into Bankman-Fried’s inbox. Dietderich, at S&C, was suggesting John Ray to sort out the disaster at FTX. Ray is one thing of a legend within the restructuring world. A 40-year-veteran of insolvency, with military-style quick gray hair, Ray has the air of a three-star common, somewhat than an lawyer. He reduce his enamel as common counsel of Fruit of the Loom when it went stomach up within the Nineties and made his identify as the person who oversaw the unwinding of Enron, the company fraud of the century. He would quickly displace Bankman-Fried as CEO.
Till Thursday, Bankman-Fried wouldn’t entertain the thought of chapter. What introduced him to the desk for talks with Miller and S&C was the pressured liquidation of FTX’s Nassau firm by Bahamas authorities. That seemed like the start of what the corporate’s US legal professionals noticed as a nightmare situation: if every of FTX’s tons of of firms from Turkey to Japan was individually pushed into chapter 11, they might be left with an unmanageable mess. Submitting within the US was the one approach to hold the method even remotely near managed.
The Bahamas staff’s struggle room moved to a close-by villa, the place Constance Wang lived. The “Conch Shack”, a 9,000-square-foot mansion with a palm-fringed pool in its courtyard, was extra personal than the penthouse. The relocation was additionally supposed to lastly permit staff members to get some sleep. Many had been up for 3 days straight.
Bankman-Fried’s inside circle was beginning to fray. Two of his closest lieutenants, Singh and Ramnik Arora, who led a lot of FTX’s previous fundraising, cracked underneath the stress. “No one had gone via a catastrophe earlier than, so folks had been breaking psychologically,” mentioned somebody near them. “It was by no means extra obvious to me how younger all of them had been than within the 72-hour interval earlier than chapter.” Arora declined to remark.
Ellison weighed in over chat from Hong Kong however appeared disengaged. Alameda had gambled vastly and been badly affected by the collapse of digital property in 2022. Ellison advised a colleague she was “relieved” that she wouldn’t have to hold the burden of operating Alameda any extra. “She felt a bit trapped,” the colleague mentioned. “It was over, even when it was a foul ‘over.’”
Folks within the struggle room started to note high executives disappearing. They hoped they had been lastly sleeping. The truth is, some had been beginning to pack up and go away.
Within the afternoon, Bankman-Fried met with Dietderich, the S&C chapter associate, on a video name. To Dietderich’s shock, the founder sat subsequent to his father. David Mills, one other Stanford Legislation professor and a white-collar professional, was additionally on the decision, together with a legal defence professional and restructuring specialist from the legislation agency Paul, Weiss. All had been appearing for Bankman-Fried personally. Dietderich bristled. S&C was working for the corporate, he mentioned in accordance with court docket data, and Bankman-Fried was a company officer with a fiduciary responsibility. The presence of the private legal professionals urged to Dietderich that Bankman-Fried was serious about his private authorized publicity. After the decision, Dietderich advised colleagues {that a} Chapter 11 submitting was imminent and referred to as in legal legislation colleagues from the agency. Mills declined to remark.
Round 8pm, S&C despatched Bankman-Fried the draft of a doc giving John Ray full management of FTX. Because the hours ticked by, with dozens of legal professionals and consultants ready, Bankman-Fried refused to signal.
EMAIL – NOV 10, 21:20
FROM: ryne miller
to: SAM BANKMAN-FRIED
Sam want this signed ASAP. Let me know.
EMAIL – NOV 10, 22:36
FROM: zach dexter
to: SAM BANKMAN-FRIED
Sam this is a wonderful decide and I wholeheartedly hope you signal this tonight. The quicker John is in place, the quicker the corporate can resolve points that require pressing progress. These of us remaining might help you considerably in the event you signal tonight.
Bankman-Fried’s legal professionals haggled over the selection of Ray and the number of new administrators for the corporate in chapter. They questioned whether or not submitting for chapter within the US would expose Bankman-Fried to extra scrutiny from American legislation enforcement, Dietderich later mentioned in court docket filings. He mentioned he advised Bankman-Fried’s counsel that the concerns about his personal curiosity had been “inappropriate.” In the meantime, Miller continued to press.
nov 10, 21:48
Ryne Miller to SBF: Howdy sir — I despatched you the doc as DocuSign. I might tremendous admire your signing it. Thanks once more for getting this piece accomplished.
Ryne Miller to Sam Bankman-Fried: MISSED CALL 22:14
nov 10, 22.36
Ryne Miller to SBF: Hello there – a delicate ping to see in the event you may signal the DocuSign I despatched. Glad to debate it with you if useful. Thanks once more.
nov 11, 00:21
SBF: Hey sorry wanting it over!
nov 11 , 00:33
Ryne Miller: We want this one. It lets the group begin to be put in place to maneuver ahead, and permits the folks making an attempt to assist start to really assist… Of us really want to begin the following section. Thanks upfront to your consideration of that perspective.
Within the early hours of Friday, FTX’s Australian subsidiary was pressured into insolvency. The unravelling envisioned by the legal professionals had begun. However Bankman-Fried nonetheless wouldn’t signal. His cellphone buzzed incessantly with messages and calls from a military of legal professionals and workers.
SIGNAL: NOV 11, 01:44
Tim Wilson: Sam, we simply acquired positioned in “voluntary” chapter in Australia by the board
SBF: understood
Tim Wilson: Sorry — however that is now getting much more pressing
Tim Wilson: Sam… I wish to assist get you snug right here, however it must occur asap.
Miller pasted a screenshot of an e mail from Dietderich within the chat:
EMAIL – NOV 10, 22:36
FROM: ANDY DIETDERICH
to: SAM BANKMAN-FRIED
Can we please have an replace? We have now many individuals in NY and Delaware ready to proceed. We have now accomplished the work we will with out Sam’s signature. If Sam is just not going to signal the instruction appointing Ray tonight, we’ll ship folks house and regroup within the morning. Australia has commenced voluntary proceedings and we will anticipate extra shortly. If Sam is signing comparatively promptly, we will keep round. Please tell us promptly if we must always proceed to attend. Andy
SIGNAL – NOV 11, 02:50
Ryne Miller: @SBF contemporary doc despatched, per directions out of your counsel. Thanks. Let me know
The FTX founder was nothing if not satisfied that he was smarter than everybody else. He had held out for days in opposition to the recommendation of the corporate’s remaining legal professionals, then its exterior counsel and at last his personal attorneys. However what modified his thoughts was mass desertion, first of his workers after which of the long-time pals round him. By Thursday evening, solely a half dozen loyalists, together with Constance and Gary, remained.
Bankman-Fried was a common with out a military. The only-page authorized doc in entrance of him gave Ray complete management over FTX and its linked firms, with energy to file them for chapter. Simply after 4am on Friday morning, he clicked the DocuSign hyperlink.
NOV 11, 07:37
Ryne Miller: The chapter filings for Alameda and FTX.com will start to begin this a.m. Perceive that @Gary Wang did superb work final evening to get many facets of the positioning in higher form. The complete FTX ecosystem seems to be ahead to with the ability to depend on of us right here to offer related data and consulting assist in coming days.
Bankman-Fried remained on the Albany. On Sunday November 13, he and Wang had been locked out of FTX’s programs by Ray’s staff. Bankman-Fried privately fumed about what he thought-about “the adults’” damaged guarantees, particularly, to seek the advice of on fundraising efforts and the appointment of administrators. Over e mail, Bankman-Fried appealed to Ray for a task within the firm’s unwinding.
EMAIL – NOV 13
FROM: SAM BANKMAN-FRIED
TO: JOHN RAY
Hey John, I’d be tremendous comfortable to talk — right here, cellphone, and so forth.! Sam
EMAIL – NOV 14
FROM: SAM BANKMAN-FRIED
TO: JOHN RAY
I’d really love to speak to you, John, and don’t want my counsel to speak first—I’m prepared/ready to speak, and suppose it could be very constructive and useful for coordination between places of work and entities for us to have a productive communicative relationship—or finally to discover having one. Sam
EMAIL – NOV 15
FROM: SAM BANKMAN-FRIED
TO: JOHN RAY
Hey John, I’d actually love to speak. We’ve been having plenty of hassle responding to the Bahamian provisional liquidators’ questions as a result of we hold getting locked out of our programs, and we’re not getting a lot of a response on that. We’d actually like to entry to our 1password accounts, and GCP, and AWS. I’d additionally simply love to speak with you and synch up so hopefully we will work constructively collectively… Please attain out anytime. Sam
EMAIL – DEC 12
FROM: SAM BANKMAN-FRIED
TO: JOHN RAY
Hello Mr Ray, I’ve probably pertinent data regarding future alternatives and financing for FTX and its collectors. I additionally consider that I’ve related monetary details about FTX US, and additional that I’ve probably related regulatory data regarding FTX. I might love to speak to you, whether or not it’s by way of e mail or cellphone, and to work constructively with you and the Chapter 11 staff to do what’s finest for purchasers… Sam.
EMAIL – JAN 2
FROM: SAM BANKMAN-FRIED
TO: JOHN RAY
Mr Ray, I do know issues haven’t gotten off on the fitting foot, however I actually do wish to be useful… As I’m guessing you’ve heard, I’m in NYC for the following day. I’d love to satisfy up whereas I’m right here — even when simply to say hello… Sam
Ray by no means replied.
In December 2022, Sam Bankman-Fried was arrested within the Bahamas and charged with orchestrating “one of many greatest monetary frauds in American historical past.” After 9 nights in custody in Nassau, he was extradited to the US, granted bail and confined to his dad and mom’ home. Caroline Ellison and Gary Wang have turned cooperating witnesses in opposition to him. Singh could also be subsequent. On January 3, the day after Bankman-Fried advised Ray he was “accessible” to satisfy in New York, he appeared in a Manhattan court docket to plead not responsible.
Earlier than assembly him in Palo Alto, the final time I spoke to Bankman-Fried in particular person was on the peak of his wealth and energy, on the balcony of a beach-front restaurant on the Albany. Sitting in his dad and mom’ home, he appeared remarkably related. He’s nonetheless a ball of nervous vitality, earnest, awkward and apparently desperate to please. As we chatted, he tapped on his laptop computer, checking baseball information and taking part in Storybook Brawl, a pc recreation. He mentioned he had no laborious emotions in direction of pals who fled or turned in opposition to him as FTX crumbled. “It was an extremely robust scenario, and it’s not what folks signed up for. And I don’t begrudge folks not wanting to stay via it.”
Since transferring house, Bankman-Fried has occupied a book-lined room the place he has parked a desk with two enormous displays in the course of the ground. To 1 facet, there’s a couch the place he continuously sleeps, though his bed room is down the corridor. When he shifts to take a seat cross-legged in his swivel chair, a attribute pose, he has to regulate the chunky black ankle monitor he wears as a situation of his confinement.
He complains of an excessive amount of down time and the chance to stew. In his den, there’s a marble slab desk with two chess units arrange facet by facet. Who does he play with? “Proper now, nobody. It’s type of there prospectively as a lot as anything,” he mentioned. He spends his days on calls with legal professionals and journalists, or writing lengthy and rambling reflections on what occurred. To date, he has produced over a thousand pages, he advised me.
By talking to the press, Bankman-Fried has shredded the playbook for legal defendants. He has more and more fixated on the chapter submitting because the pivotal error. On Twitter and in his writing and interviews, he rails in opposition to Miller and S&C for pushing FTX into chapter 11, blaming them for shutting off rescue routes he insists would have let him pay again clients. Bankman-Fried claims he had no concept about Wilson’s or Ray’s historical past with S&C and claims this strengthens his argument that S&C conspired to pressure him into chapter 11, appoint its hand-picked CEO and pocket hundreds of thousands in authorized charges. (S&C, Miller and Ray have rejected his claims.) “He nonetheless thinks that if chapter had by no means been filed, all the pieces would have been okay,” says somebody who is aware of Bankman-Fried properly.
Bankman-Fried admitted he has been dwelling on what’s going to occur if he’s discovered responsible of fees that carry a possible life sentence. Subsequent to the chess units is a stack of printed authorized paperwork. Considering again to the ultimate days of FTX, he mentioned it appeared to him that his pals and advisers had been warped by the stress. “It felt to me like everybody round me had misplaced their minds all of sudden. And everyone seems to be behaving bizarrely poorly,” he mentioned. “I did really feel type of like there have been no adults left within the room, like everyone seems to be a toddler now.”
Bankman-Fried’s defence is that he screwed up. However he nonetheless seems like a child anticipating to be slapped on the wrist. Outdoors his sanctuary in Palo Alto, many of the world has concluded that he’s an grownup and that he’s at fault, leaving solely the tiny oasis of his dad and mom’ house the place the alternative would possibly nonetheless be true.
Joshua Oliver is the FT’s asset administration reporter. Further reporting by William Langley and Chan Ho-him in Hong Kong, Sujeet Indap in New York and Nikou Asgari and Kadhim Shubber in London
Observe @FTMag on Twitter to seek out out about our newest tales first
